Is this ‘recovery’ already fading?

There are several signs in the wind that Osborne’s ‘recovery’, which he so relentlessly talks up at every opportunity, is not going anywhere.   Carney, Osborne’s man at the BoE, has declared the recovery “neither balance nor sustainable”.   It is certainly not balanced, despite all the rhetoric about bringing that about, as the chasm between finance and manufacturing grows ever wider.   Nor is is sustainable when its foundation in household credit expansion is clearly limited by the continuing fall in wages and when the real pillars of sustainability – business investment, high productivity and rising net exports remain prominent by their absence.   From another direction altogether which must make Osborne wince, the hedge fund king Soros has been putting his deep pockets where his scepticism leads him, which is not to back what seems the inexorable rise in the US stock market, and by extension the FTSE recovery.   This is the man who gambled against the £ in the face of huge self-confident government hype, as now (but then by Tory Chancellor Norman Lamont), and forced it out of the ERM in 1992 and then got it right in predicting the credit crunch 15 years later, so his opinion is worth taking seriously when he’s put a huge bet behind it.

But the whole issue begs the question: what is meant by economic growth?   There is the growing polarisation between the 1% and the 99%, between London and the rest of the country, between the swelling army of the lowest paid and the comfortably well-off.   So what sense does it make to talk about averages spanning such incommensurables?    Moreover, what sense does it make when the economy is increasingly financialised, i.e. ‘growth’ reflects financial transactions which don’t actually make anything while manufacturing, which does, wilts ever further?   What this means is that the ONS and OBR figures so confidently peddled every month or every 3 months no longer reflect the reality on the ground.

This was recently confirmed by published data on the car industry, the one manufacturing area which has been acclaimed as a great British success story.   UK factories have increased car production by 45% over the last 4 years, but over the same period the average director of the 6 largest car makers have taken home a 19% increase in pay while the average real terms salary increase has been just 2.3% and the wages of the lowest paid third of the workforce have fallen over 7% (according to ONS figures).   So over the last decade employees in the finance industry, overwhelmingly in London, have increased their share of national income from 1% to 15% but not produced anything, manufacturing has continued to shrink mainly because the exchange rate is still too high, the rise in agency workers and temporary contracts even in Britain’s most successful industry (motor vehicles) has pushed down wages despite rocketing sales, and 4m workers still get paid below the Living Wage.   Call that growth?

2 thoughts on “Is this ‘recovery’ already fading?

  1. Mr.Meacher I really despair in what this un-elected government are doing to the UK. I feel the public in general are starting to question the misleading propaganda spewed out of the right wing press on a daily basis.

    I have just read the tories have deleted from the internet all their pre-election manifesto broadcasts and speeches, just in case the public are reminded about their lies / promises. Doesn’t that say a great deal about what they represent.

    I recall one of Cameron’s televised displays of his concern for the environment, he appeared on TV riding his bike to work ” Saving the Planet” was the theme. (The chauffer driven limousine following behind) What a showman should have been a comedian, may have had more success.

    My thanks for all your efforts and articles and your passion for social equality.

  2. ah off track saving the planet look at those sates in usa were water is polluted with gas heavy metals its one way of killing usoff end
    you posted the car
    This was recently confirmed by published data on the car industry, the one manufacturing area which has been acclaimed as a great British success story. yes it was a false figure has of the rich buying up the expensives modelsthis figures they distorted using them to show a recovery but us plebbs cant afford new ones yet the rich get richer whist they with carney in the bank fiddle the figures yes mt English is rubbish but then onehasnt a brain dying on you but hope one isrefreshed to show us that tony blairs in the labour party are not our way but more to the left has you with ed seem to think labour can survive with the unions is this modern labour then the working man will make a new party up for it to be heard ask ed he isn’t listening one bit leave the blair years go they hurt labour sorry little tory party but we will be heard perhaps not in the time I have but us the ordinary people will be heard not killed of with this lot and their sanctions please itsgetting late and many die while you all discuss this its time to shine andshow weaint without hope jeff without the three has our plight is beyond now its like that bit were it goes in thesummer of 41 65 thousand you now the history they passed this figure already

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *